Vacancy taxes: How Canadian property owners are impacted
Over the year, a number of new taxes impacting owners of real property in Canada have come into effect. The Underused Housing Tax, Vacant Home Tax, and Vacant Unit Tax are three examples of these new “vacancy” taxes intended to disincentivize holding properties that are not being lived in or rented out.
What is the Underused Housing Tax?
The Underused Housing Tax (UHT) is a new federal tax starting in 2022. The UHT is a one per cent tax payable by certain holders of Canadian real estate and calculated on the market value of the property. The tax will apply beginning January 1, 2022, with the first UHT returns being due on April 30, 2023.
Why is it important to be aware of the UHT?
The UHT is intended to target foreign owners of Canadian real estate who are not making productive use of the property. Despite the intended target, the UHT can have significant implications for property holders within Canada.
Although most property owners located in Canada will not be required to pay the tax, many will still be required to file returns. In many situations, a return must be filed to claim an exemption from the tax.
If an individual is required to file a UHT return and fails to do so, they are subject to a minimum penalty of $5,000 and may lose access to exemptions that would otherwise apply to eliminate the tax owing. If the non-compliant owner is not an individual, the minimum penalty is $10,000, however, there is no impact on certain exemptions available to the entity. A separate return is required for each residential property, with penalties assessed on each return.
Which properties does the UHT apply to?
Properties to which the UHT can apply are referred to as “residential properties”.
A residential property is any house or similar building with no more than three dwelling units and any portion of a building that is intended to be owned apart from any other unit in the building.
For example, owners of detached and semi-detached houses, duplexes, triplexes, or condominium units may need to file a UHT return and pay the tax.
Traditional apartment buildings are not subject to UHT, as the units (apartments) are not intended to be owned apart from other units in the building.
Who must file a UHT return?
A UHT return must be filed by every owner of a residential property unless they are an excluded owner. An owner is generally the person identified as the property holder in the land registry or similar system. There are some special situations in which a tenant may be considered an owner for the purposes of the UHT, such as when the tenant has the option to purchase the land they are renting.
Where a nominee or bare trust is used to hold a property on behalf of another entity, it will be the nominee or bare trust that is viewed as the owner and is required to file a UHT return, unless they are an excluded owner.
The determination of whether an owner qualifies as an excluded owner occurs on December 31st of each year. An owner will qualify if they are:
- A citizen or permanent resident of Canada
- A Canadian corporation with shares traded on a registered Canadian stock exchange
- A trustee of a trust with units traded on a registered Canadian exchange
- A registered charity
- A cooperative housing corporation, hospital authority, municipality, public college, school authority, or university
- An indigenous governing body
The definition of an excluded owner does not include private corporations (other than registered charities), estates, personal trusts, or partnerships. If a residential property is held by one of these entities, a UHT return will be required. This return is required regardless of whether the owner will have a UHT balance owing.
There is no carve-out from filing requirements for newcomers to Canada. If a person living in Canada is neither a citizen or a permanent resident, they will be required to file a UHT return.
The rules have the opposite impact on Canadian citizens living abroad. As the definition of excluded owner does not consider current residency, a person with Canadian citizenship will never be required to file a UHT return, regardless of the use of their property in Canada or the country in which they currently live.
Despite being required to file a UHT return, there are various exemptions available to shield owners from paying UHT.
Who must pay UHT?
There are several exemptions available that must be claimed on a UHT return to exempt the filer from tax. Some of these exemptions apply to multiple properties, while others will not.
One of the most significant exemptions is for specified Canadian corporations, trusts, and partnerships. These entities are eligible for a full exemption from UHT, and as such will not have any tax owing on their filings. The requirements for these exemptions are outlined below:
|Full exemption for "Specified Canadian Corporations"
A Canadian corporation for which less than 10 per cent of its votes and value are held directly or indirectly by a combination of:
|Personal trust or estate
|Full exemption for “Specified Canadian Trusts”
|A trust under which each beneficiary with a beneficial interest in the residential property is an excluded owner or specified Canadian corporation
|Full exemption for “Specified Canadian Partnerships”
|A partnership with all partners being excluded owners or specified Canadian corporations
The eligibility for these exemptions is determined on December 31st of the year. As such, it is possible to perform a reorganization to meet the exemption before year end.
As noted earlier in this article, these specified Canadian entities are required to file UHT returns and are subject to a minimum penalty of $10,000 (per residential property) if returns are filed late. As such, although these entities will not be required to pay UHT, it is essential that returns are filed on time.
Some other exemptions which could apply to fully exempt an owner from UHT include:
- Exemptions for uninhabitable properties (due to disaster, hazardous condition, or renovation)
- Exemption for the first year of ownership
- Exemption related to the death of the owner
- Exemption for the property being used as a primary place of residence
If no other exemptions are available to exempt the property from UHT for the year, the qualifying occupancy exemption may be available. This exemption is designed so that the UHT applies only to underused property. If a property is in use (either by the owner or tenants) for the qualifying occupancy exemption will generally be available to exempt the property from UHT.
Note: allowing friends or family to use the property for low or no rent may fall outside of the qualifying occupancy exemption, and result in UHT being payable.
Many of the above exemptions have criteria that must be met to claim them. It is recommended that care be taken to ensure that an exemption is available before filing the UHT return.
New municipal vacancy taxes
The Vacant Home Tax (VHT) and Vacant Unit Tax (VUT) are two other new taxes targeting vacant or underused residential properties. The VHT specifically applies to all owners of residential property located in Toronto, Ontario, whilst the VUT applies to all owners of residential property located in Ottawa, Ontario.
These taxes apply effective January 1, 2022, with the first related filings or declarations due on February 2, 2023, for declarations under the VHT and March 16, 2023, for the VUT. Failure to file these declarations will result in a minimum penalty of $250, and if the declarations are not filed by April 30th
Any person or entity holding a residential property, as determined under the existing property tax system, in Toronto or Ottawa must make one of these declarations per property. There is no exemption from the filing requirement like there is under UHT. As a result, citizens of Canada living abroad may be required to pay these taxes.
Similar to UHT, the amount of tax owing will be calculated as one per cent of the value of the vacant property. A residential property will be considered vacant if it has not had a person living in it for at least six months of the prior year unless an exemption applies. Exemptions are similar to UHT, where the tax will not apply if vacancy was due to safety concerns, renovations, or the death of the previous owner, among other exemptions.
These taxes will be implemented as part of the existing property tax system, with any taxes owing being charged on the normal property tax statement for the property.
These new vacancy taxes will have a major impact on owners of property located in Canada, regardless of where they reside. Care should be taken to ensure that all required returns and declarations are filed on time to avoid the imposition of significant penalties and the potential imposition of tax where exemptions would otherwise be available.
If you are a Fuller Landau client and have questions about these new taxes, please reach out to your engagement partner.
About the authors
Jennifer So, CPA, CGA is a Senior Manager in our Canadian Tax group. She can be reached a email@example.com or 416-645-6549.
Robert Davies, CPA is a Manager in our Canadian Tax group. He can be reached at firstname.lastname@example.org or 416-645-6507.